In February 2021, it was announced that a fan favorite franchise – EA’s College Football – would be returning. The franchise was discontinued following licensing issues in 2014. Now almost a decade later, the game is back and arguably better than its closest rival Madden 25. 

With the exception of a couple athletes, EA was able to get licensing for all FBS teams and players. This allows fans to take over their favorite college and act as the coach for the team. Whether that’s keeping a dynasty alive like Alabama or Georgia or taking a smaller school to the top, the game offers many options that allow for replay-ability. Players can also play as their own collegiate athlete in the “Road to Glory” game mode, which also brings more options to experience.

College Football 25 adds something different for football fans. Madden, which has been around ever since 1988, has produced a new game every year. Although there are changes from game to game, fans often feel like there is no huge difference from the current edition and the one released two or three years ago. Nonetheless, it still provides the most authentic experience for players who want to play with their favorite NFL teams and players, due to EA having full rights over them. 

Just because College Football 25 is long awaited, doesn’t mean it’s a perfect product. Fans say that certain parts of the game can feel bland and lack detail. They also left out some fan favorite game modes from CFB 14, like “Mascot Mode” and “Heisman.” There are also glitches within the gameplay, like random dropped passes and missed tackles.

Overall both games are good in their own right. It all comes down to personal preference, and what kind of atmosphere you want to be around. Some people love the crowd and challenge of college football, while others like the professionalism and feeling of Madden. Overall, College Football 25 allows for more opportunities and options to play, while providing a new and fresh experience, making it the more enjoyable game this year.